Despite a record number of MTO staff attending our HOT Lanes Forum in January, the Ontario government decided to use 1988 technology from Utah.

Province’s new HOT lanes are lukewarm at best

GUELPH, September 15, 2016 — Having facilitated Canada’s only continuous mobility pricing conversation since 2008, Transport Futures (TF) remains unimpressed with the roll-out of the Ontario Government’s High Occupancy Toll (HOT) lanes pilot project today.

“We’re surprised that the government has chosen such a low-tech approach when it comes to Canada’s first HOT Lanes project”, says Martin Collier, TF founder.  “Besides the fact that there is 20 years of US experience that could have been replicated, the province has chosen to launch a HOT pilot that is lukewarm at best.”

Collier says that there are many problems with the HOT pilot but the flat $60 per month permit price may be the worst.  “Road tolling of any type must be priced properly to provide the proper signal to drivers so they consider using GO Transit and other sustainable modes.”

Commuting five days per week between Oakville and Burlington, drivers using their HOT Permit in two directions will spend a maximum of $3.00/day in comparison to a return GO Presto fare of $6.44 – which increases by $3.22 with each subsequent trip. Even with the HOT price, travelling by car costs a maximum of 47% of a GO Presto fare – and drivers participating in the pilot receive the benefits of the faster trip in the HOT Lane and don’t need to look for parking or wait at the station. 

“While we understand that the province was concerned about driver participation rates during the pilot, the per trip price should be at least equal to the GO Presto fare price.  For the next phase starting in January, we encourage the province to increase the permit price to $129.00 per month (maximum $6.45 per day) in order to level the playing field between drivers and transit users travelling in this specific corridor.”

– 30 –